Sean K. Cureton

The Avengers: Movie Review

In Movie Reviews: 2012 on May 29, 2012 at 6:06 pm

Theatrical Poster

The Avengers
3 out of 4 stars
Directed by Joss Whedon

Last summer was a bad time for super hero movies made by Marvel Studios. Marvel released a total of three films, each of which was a dud in one-way or another. Matthew Vaughn’s X-men: First Class failed to take advantage of the fresh start that was being offered in the reboot of the series, scrapping any plans that were originally put forth by initial X-men adapter Bryan Singer, and producing a film that had less to do with the rich back story and mythology of the original comic series, and instead offering more of the same Hollywood mixed bag of characters from the series in a ludicrous, if admittedly entertaining, package that viewers have come to expect since Brett Ratner’s desecration of the film series in 2006. In addition, there were the releases of Thor and Captain America: The First Avenger, which were both films that fell flat in terms of providing characters with engaging personalities and character arcs. Thus, Marvel Studios had a lot riding on this summer’s release of The Avengers, which is faced with the task of integrating the Iron Man, Thor, Captain America, and Incredible Hulk films into a coherent and cohesive whole.

Luckily for the film studio, Joss Whedon’s film was able to bridge the gaps that had been left open by the other films while simultaneously fixing the damage that had been done by the other less than knowledgeable directors’ efforts. The Avengers is funny, loyal to the comics, and absolutely awe-inspiring at every turn. Whedon, a veteran of producing geekier fare on both TV and the big screen, clearly understands just what it is that both the fans of Marvel movies and core fans of the comics love so much about the Marvel universe. Instead of trying to fit as many action sequences into each frame of the film in order to keep the film moving, as was certainly the case with the Cap film of last summer, Whedon revels in the quiet moments where the characters can develop the relationships between each other, which builds tension and anticipation for the action that inevitably breaks out.

However, one thing that still seems to separate Whedon’s behemoth of a super hero film from such flawless fare as Sam Raimi’s adaptation of Spiderman or Bryan Singer’s X2, is the feeling of exclusion that seems to be present in Whedon’s universe. Where Branagh’s Thor was a film that was obviously heavily based on the comic series, the film itself seemed to branch out a little more from this source material in order for Branagh to put his own touch into the film, making it less of a comic book guy’s film and more of a collaboration of a movie that a larger audience unfamiliar with comics could enjoy along with core fans. Whedon’s knowledge of the Avengers universe is very clear in the film’s writing, which is something that might deter and alienate older viewers who have not grown up with or immersed themselves in the universe quiet as heavily as Whedon and his core viewers have. Thus, The Avengers isn’t truly a great film even though it is a flawless comic book movie. In order to be a great movie, the material at hand would have had to have been molded or influenced more precisely by an outsider, as is the case with Nolan’s impressive Dark Knight Trilogy, which bridges the gap perfectly between the average super hero film and the larger category of truly exceptional and great films.

In conclusion, Joss Whedon’s The Avengers fixes all of the problems that were present in the movies that had been leading up to its release, providing the Marvel film that fans have been awaiting eagerly for years now. However, Whedon’s film is set in a universe that is distinctly of the comic book world, which is a world that is filled with back story and mythology that only the most dedicated, or at least nominally interested, comic reader will truly be able to appreciate. I suppose that Nolan will remain the only visionary director in the crafting of great films about super heroes while Whedon’s film is simply a great super hero movie. And that’s a pretty big difference in my opinion.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: